Olive That! and More

246 Bellevue Ave, Montclair, N.J.
973.744.7175

Our story is all about a passion for life

Our love and appreciation of olive oil has been an evolution from a slow start (perhaps a drizzle) to true inspiration (call it a pour) based on our extensive travels and adventures in the kitchen.

Our Story

Olive That and More is family-owned and operated by husband and wife team Steve Lehrhoff and Jennifer O’Sullivan (even our young son, Graham, has been known to recommend Mom’s Meyer Lemon Pound Cake to customers). Our love and appreciation of olive oil has been an evolution from a slow start (perhaps a drizzle) to true inspiration (call it a pour) based on our extensive travels and adventures in the kitchen. The inspiration led to a desire to bring the finest and freshest products from around the world back home. Located in the heart of Montclair, New Jersey you can find over 30 varieties of olive oil, 10 choices of Aged Balsamic Vinegars, over a dozen choices in sea salts.  We like to call Olive That and More a “store with taste” because everyone who enters is encouraged to enjoy all the flavors and imagine how you might mix and match to create your next favorite combination!